Infocus-magazine.com Florida TV Film Industry News
The Debut


The Debut is written and directed by Jesse Eisenberg, who also plays a role in the offbeat film. Julianne Moore stars as Mona, a mousy housewife. Her sweaters buttoned up, her shoes always sensible, she’s desperate to find some meaning and relevance in her banal existence. Ignored by her husband and two kids, who laugh easily, have better stories and more exciting friends, it’s obvious that she feels invisible.


As the film opens, Mona has plucked up her courage; she auditions for a role in a musical at her small-town repertory theater. The role is of a janitor/building superintendent in charge of a crappy, run-down apartment building. Ironically, her character is the ‘fixer’ of all things broken, and none are more broken than our Mona.

The theater director, Jerry, is played by Paul Giamatti, who is absolutely stellar in the role of the sometimes-tyrannical leader of the playhouse. He’s simultaneously loved and hated by those around him, and he uses that to get what he wants out of the cast.


That’s what The Debut is about, on the surface. But if we dig a little deeper, we discover the intent of The Debut is to address the masks we humans recycle throughout our lives, donning and shedding them, based on the circumstances in which we find ourselves. There are several shots of the two classic theater masks, comedy and tragedy, sprinkled throughout the film, in case you miss Eisenberg’s obvious hints.


And no one sports their masks more perfectly, more frequently, and more transparently fraudulently, than the cast of characters in this musical. The show they’re bringing to the town is called ‘Nosy Neighbors’, and this is one musical that never, ever should be produced. The songs are purposely awful, as are the situations into which the characters are thrust. There is no one and nothing remotely relatable to any audience member who has an iota of taste. And I’m sure that’s the point. It’s unrealistic.

Giamatti’s Jerry insists the show is a beloved classic, one that must never be changed, no set direction revised, no word amended, because ‘that’s how it was written, that’s what the playwright intended.’ The actors, including Eisenberg, Halle Berry and Bernadette Peters are wedded completely to the words in the script. To make things even worse, when they’re away from the floodlights, every single one of them is still as fake and artificial as the characters they portray when they’re on stage. I mean teeth-gratingly saccharine-sweet fake.


They’re so over the top annoying that I wasn’t sure if Mona, was dreaming the entire thing. The casting call and her flop of an audition seemed real enough. For a while I wasn’t sure if she went home, knowing she flubbed it, fell asleep, and what came after was just some bizarre 90-minute dream sequence.


Yet there are occasions when Mona and Jerry drop their masks and their true selves are revealed. Those instances happen when they’re angry, or frightened, and, most importantly, challenged. When they feel some true emotion. Not that love or happiness aren’t true emotions, but these scenes are the most electric in the film. We see and feel the trueness of these two characters when they challenge each other, which make those scenes the best part of The Debut.


The potential of what might happen if we tweak our assigned roles in life is thematically important here. That story arc, when Jerry pushes Mona to stop playing a role in her own life and start living, arises very late in the film. Yes, we’re definitely relieved that Mona starts to break the chains that have constrained her for decades. ‘If you don’t try, you’ll never know’ applies to Mona’s role in the film as well as her station in life, but I wish it had come a little earlier in the film. I wanted her to take some sweet revenge.

Share Story